All mistakes/Section 1: The Foundations Every Task Must Get Right
1.1The deliverable sits below the complexity bar
Fails a client CORE standard
The mistake
The deliverable misses its type's complexity floor. Typically the Agent Objective says dashboard, no prompt asks for interaction, and the page ships static.
Do this instead
Before prompt 1, check the deliverable type against its floor, and have a prompt ask for the interaction the data supports.
Where it happened
One real task. Each shows the spot and what it should have been; click any line to open the task there.
the words at faultthe row or field at faultmissing from the taskwhat is righta task file
Example 1Commerce & Product · 3 Leg A turns
What is wrongThe Agent Objective asks for "one local HTML dashboard"; the golden ada_list.html has no script, button, filter or link. Static, it clears neither the dashboard nor the interactive HTML floor.
Controls that respond: the list sorts by price and hides what Fresh does not stock.
How it breaks the standardNothing on ada_list.html responds, so the task ships a document, the lowest priority type on the Complexity Bar, though 14 Fresh orders could feed sorting or filters. Model A and Model B never see the Agent Objective, and no Leg A prompt asks for interaction, so no criterion grades it.
Ask what the page does when someone clicks it. If nothing, it is a document, whatever the Agent Objective calls it.
Where the correct guidance is written
Section titles as they print, so you can search for them in the document.
Guidelines · Complexity Bar
Interactive HTML: Interaction that actually works: controls that respond, state that changes, filters or navigation. A styled static page does not qualify. Dashboard: Several linked views over data the model extracted itself. One chart is not a dashboard.
Both are P0 floors.
Guidelines · 1.3 Defining the Draft History
The Draft History (Agent Objective, Desired Outcome, Multimodal Upload) is not embedded in the agent by default.
So only a prompt can ask for a dashboard.
Why it matters
A page that does nothing when clicked clears neither the interactive HTML floor nor the dashboard floor. It is a document, the lowest priority deliverable on the bar, so the task falls short of what the client asked for however good the reasoning underneath is. The deliverable is set by the prompts at scenario stage, so it cannot be patched later.
Example 1The deliverable sits below the complexity barFails a client CORE standard
Commerce & Product3 Leg A turnstask 6aa73af2a7b183d5fb7eb8bb
From the taskAgent Objective
Winslow Achebe is picky about grocery brands, and this time, Adaeze is the one going to the store. While he was writing his shopping list, someone at the office pushed some cheaper lookalike products on him. He needs one local HTML dashboard, 'ada_list.html ', that Ada can use at the store, where his sticky list becomes a detailed shop sheet (brand, product, price, amount, and product picture), and it includes a clear comparison of the tip products against what he already buys on Amazon Fresh, with a fixed KEEP TIP or SKIP TIP call.
From the taskEvery Leg A prompt, to Model A
Leg A turn 1
Ada called; she's going to the store after work, and I was making my list for her when I was told I could change some products. I got some pics of the products (proteinbars.png, gfacts.png, and gimage.png), and I need to create a comparison table for the products I usually buy, coz I'm really picky about my things. I also need to create an "ada_list.html" where I need to have the items from the list I uploaded, with the amounts I usually buy. It should be detailed, like brand, price, size, and a pic of them, so Ada doesn't get them wrong.
Leg A turn 2
I only asked for one HTML. I need you to check the swaps with this rule: KEEP TIP only when the new product is lower priced than my usual and organic. Protein should be at least 10g, and the OJ should have Calcium and vitamin D. Otherwise, SKIP TIP.
Leg A turn 3
Okay, that's better for comparison, but you didn't really research either. Also, the page should be focused on the list first, and you are asking me to write the data you have. It needs brand, price, size, amount, and a product picture. Don't invent it you have the data.
From the taskGolden artifacts archive
ada_list.html.html1309 KB
Task fileada_list.html
Look at The golden page, running here as it shipped. Try to sort, filter or switch a view: nothing on it responds, because no prompt asked for anything that would.